Thread:Visfvifsgjjsvjgsjmdsgs/@comment-27002267-20190520091801

Hi, I wanted to point out some issues with the modifications you have made to the categories of the character pages.

First of all, I believe the "Not Present" category is ambiguous as well as superfluous. "Not present" could be interpreted in many ways - characters who are deceased, characters who are no longer a member of the band, characters who have graduated from the school, characters who are not playing an active role in the series et cetera. This ambiguity defeats the purpose of a category, which is to organize articles by similar features which can be easily noted to the user. And all of the above-mentioned interpretations of the category can be easily understood from the information in the articles which you have added to the category, hence I do not think such category is necessary in this wiki.

You have also reverted the categories of the band members to having their year/grade status as in they were in the main series instead of the current releases. While I understand that the main series is the most prominent arc of the story, the information and categories of articles should be updated to reflect the current status of the character in the newest official release, which, right now, is the Finale Oath movie. It is factually incorrect to categorize a character as a "Second Year" when they are in fact a "Third Year" in the current arc of the series. The infobox and the character introduction paragraph preserves all necessary information of the character from the main series, so I hope you can understand that categories are to be the reflection of the character in their latest appearance in the series.

Finally, I just want you to note that making a major change across many articles should not be based solely on one user's input. If you feel a need to make a significant change, post it on the wiki forum or the community feeds and we will discuss as a community as to what action we should take. Once we reach a consensus, you are welcome to make the agreed changes. If you have conflicting ideas with another user's edit/s, leave a message on their wall and talk it out. This is so disputes and edit wars can be avoided.

I want to thank you for your immense contribution and devotion to the wiki thus far, but there are just a few things you should note before making large edits. Please don't hesitate to ask questions, we are all here to help. :) 